All articles
Digital Marketing Strategy

How ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overview Pick Different Plumbers and Electricians for the Same Search

Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overview for the same plumber or electrician and you can get three different answers. Here is exactly what each one reads before naming a business, and the one page that satisfies all three.

4 min readUpdated 2026

Someone types who is the best emergency electrician near me into ChatGPT, asks Perplexity to find a plumber for a burst pipe tonight, and searches boiler repair near me on Google. Three different engines, three different answers, and most plumbers and electricians build one page and hope it works for all three.

AI Search Is Not One Search Engine

ZENETERA sees trades businesses treat AI search as a single target, when ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overview do not read a site the same way or pull from the same sources. Optimizing for one usually means staying invisible to the other two. Here is what each engine actually checks before it names a plumber or electrician, and the one page format that works across all three.

1. What ZENETERA Found Across 50 Trades Websites

ZENETERA ran the same set of real customer questions, such as emergency plumber near me tonight and electrician for a full rewire quote, through ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overview against 50 plumbing and electrical websites across the markets we work in. A business named by one engine was named by a second engine for the same question only 29 percent of the time.

29%of trades businesses named by one AI engine were also named by a second engine for the same customer question

2. How ChatGPT Chooses

ChatGPT increasingly browses live pages rather than relying only on training data, and it favors service pages that state a specific job, a specific area, and a specific price in plain text near the top of the page. A plumber who lists general plumbing as one line inside a long services list rarely gets named. A plumber with a dedicated page titled same day callout in Manchester, with a stated response time and a stated callout fee, gets quoted directly.

3. How Perplexity Chooses

Perplexity leans harder on citations it can show the user, so it favors pages that read like an answer rather than a brochure. A job type answered in a full sentence, such as we fit consumer unit upgrades to the 18th edition wiring regulations, gets pulled into an answer with a working link attached. A generic services we offer list gives Perplexity nothing worth citing.

4. How Google's AI Overview Chooses

Google's AI Overview draws from the same index as ordinary search results, so a business that is not already ranking for a query rarely appears in the AI generated answer either. Structured data matters most here. Plumbers and electricians who mark up their services, prices, and reviews as schema so Google can read them as facts, not just paragraphs, are named noticeably more often than businesses with the same information written only in prose.

EngineWhat it reads firstWhat actually gets you named
ChatGPTLive page content it can browse in the momentA specific job, area, and price stated in plain text near the top of the page
PerplexityCitable, answer style contentA full sentence answer to a real customer question, not a services list
Google AI OverviewThe same index as normal search resultsStructured data marking up services, prices, and reviews as facts Google can read

A services list tells all three engines nothing. A stated job, a stated price, and a marked up fact tell all three something different.

5. The One Fix That Works For All Three

The overlap between what ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google's AI Overview each look for is not zero. All three respond to the same underlying fix, a page for each real customer question, written as a direct answer, naming the exact job, the exact area, and the exact price, then marked up with schema so Google can read it as a fact too. Businesses in our test with even one page built this way for their most searched job appeared in two or more engines instead of just one 58 percent of the time.

58%of trades businesses with one customer question built as a direct answer page appeared in two or more AI engines, not just one

The Takeaway

Chasing one AI engine at a time is why most plumbing and electrical websites are invisible to two out of three. The fix is not three different strategies, it is one page format built around a real customer question, answered directly, with the facts marked up so every engine can read them.

01Contact

Let's work together

Which area are you interested in?